Brunch in Delaware County
The 5 brunch spots that local best-of lists name most often. We read 6 lists from local papers, magazines and food writers, counted who shows up, and link every one.
The list
Own one of these? Verify it free to set your own hours and links.
Hamburger Inn Diner
Downtown diner open since 1932; regulars seat themselves at the counters and order the cinnamon rolls.
Named by Breakfast with Nick, Columbus Diner Guide (page undated, read Oct 31, 2026) · Destination Delaware County, Your Guide to Downtown Delaware for a First-Time Visitor (Aug 7, 2025) · DelawareO, Rise and Dine: Discover Delaware, Ohio's Top 5 Breakfast Spots (Dec 14, 2024) · Columbus Monthly, Our Guide to the Top Places to Eat and Drink in Downtown Delaware (Aug 2023), Breakfast Options
The Rutherford Cafe
Sandwich cafe on East William Street; regulars go for breakfast sandwiches, wraps and bagels with lox.
Named by DelawareO, Rise and Dine: Discover Delaware, Ohio's Top 5 Breakfast Spots (Dec 14, 2024) · Columbus Monthly, Our Guide to the Top Places to Eat and Drink in Downtown Delaware (Aug 2023)
3 Brothers Diner
Olentangy Street diner mixing Mexican, Cuban and American breakfasts, with a big bar and a patio.
The Pancake House Family Diner
Family-run diner known for pancakes paired with Venezuelan breakfasts, plus gelato made on site.
Named by Breakfast with Nick, Columbus Breakfast Guide, Four More to Try (page undated, read Oct 31, 2026) · Breakfast with Nick, Columbus Diner Guide (page undated, read Oct 31, 2026)
Fresh Start Cafe & Bakery
Downtown bakery cafe with croissants, cinnamon rolls, quiche and breakfast sandwiches made to order.
Named by DelawareO, Rise and Dine: Discover Delaware, Ohio's Top 5 Breakfast Spots (Dec 14, 2024)
How this list is ranked
Each place gets a point for every recent local best-of list that names it: readers' choice results, local papers and magazines, food writers. Review-site top tens count half. Newer lists break ties. Nobody can pay to be on it. When reader votes come in, they count too.
Think we missed a place? Tell us which list named it and we'll recount.